top of page

ADS-L: An Analysis

5 days ago
10 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

Electronic conspicuity is intended to improve safety in airspace. However, the current implementation of ADS-L raises fundamental questions. Why are ADS-L and FLARM not fully compatible, even though they use the same radio technology? And why does the planned equipment mandate in Switzerland primarily require transmission, but not reception?


Improving safety through electronic conspicuity


Airspace is shared by many different types of aircraft: paragliders, hang gliders, sailplanes, powered aircraft, helicopters, and increasingly drones.


Particularly in the Alps, these aircraft often operate in the same airspace. However, their speeds and manoeuvrability differ considerably.


A powered aircraft approaching a paraglider at a relative speed of 200 km/h covers more than 550 metres in just ten seconds. Even in good visibility, it is therefore not always possible to detect other aircraft in time.


A report commissioned by EASA estimates the detection rate of the "See and Avoid" principle at only 40 to 60 percent.


Electronic systems can make an important contribution to safety. They allow aircraft to transmit their own position and receive position information from other aircraft. With suitable algorithms, this information can be used to generate warnings of potentially dangerous encounters.


The objective should therefore be clear: Every pilot should be able to detect other aircraft in time and be detected by others.


ADS-L: A standard for electronic conspicuity


The European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) has developed ADS-L (Automatic Dependent Surveillance – Light), an open standard for electronic conspicuity.


ADS-L enables position data to be transmitted in the licence-free 868 MHz band using inexpensive, energy-efficient radio equipment. Unlike conventional ADS-B systems, it does not require complex certified avionics.


In December 2025, EASA published Issue 2 of the ADS-L 4 SRD860 technical specification. Among other improvements, this version introduces the possibility of transmitting traffic information from ground stations to aircraft.


At XC Tracer, we fundamentally welcome this development. An open, manufacturer-independent standard is an important step towards greater safety. However, the current implementation still has significant shortcomings.


ADS-L Out is not the same as ADS-L In


Two different functions must be distinguished:


  • ADS-L Out: A device transmits its own position so that other aircraft can detect it.

  • ADS-L In: A device receives position information from other aircraft and can use it for traffic displays or collision warnings.


A device equipped with ADS-L Out only makes its pilot electronically visible. However, it does not provide any information about other aircraft nearby.


Imagine two paragliders, both equipped with ADS-L Out. Both transmit their positions. But since neither device receives ADS-L, neither pilot knows where the other is.


Both are electronically visible – but neither can make use of this information.


Only when at least one of the two devices can also receive ADS-L does its pilot become aware of the other's position. With suitable processing, this information can be used to generate collision warnings.


ADS-L Out provides the basis for electronic conspicuity. ADS-L In makes that information useful to the receiving pilot.


For effective collision warning, we need both.


The planned ADS-L mandate in Switzerland

The Swiss Federal Office of Civil Aviation (FOCA) is working on a mandatory electronic conspicuity requirement as part of the FASST-CH programme.


According to our information, the regulation is expected to be adopted in 2027, with implementation planned for 2028 following a one-year transition period.


For paragliders and hang gliders, FOCA currently considers ADS-L Out to be the required standard for electronic visibility to other airspace users. According to FOCA, a device with ADS-L In/Out should be "considered", particularly for more manoeuvrable aircraft. However, reception is not mandatory.


We understand the desire to keep costs and technical complexity as low as possible for pilots. Nevertheless, we are critical of this limitation.


If thousands of pilots transmit their positions in the future but cannot receive position data from other aircraft, a significant part of the potential safety benefit will remain unused.

There is also a risk of creating a false sense of security. Pilots using ADS-L Out should not automatically assume that other aircraft can actually detect them electronically.


In the longer term, mandatory equipment requirements should therefore address not only transmission but also the reception and use of traffic information.


FLARM and ADS-L: Same radio technology, but incompatible

FLARM has been a widely used electronic collision warning system for many years. Particularly in gliding, FLARM has pioneered electronic collision avoidance and made an important contribution to improving flight safety.


ADS-L defines several radio channels. The so-called M-band uses the same frequencies as FLARM, namely 868.2 and 868.4 MHz, as well as the same basic transmission technology. Nevertheless, many existing FLARM receivers cannot receive ADS-L packets.


This is remarkable because the EASA specification explicitly states that these radio channels were partly derived from existing FLARM and PilotAware systems to improve interoperability and enable cost-effective retrofits.


FLARM itself points out on its website that most existing devices can monitor only one receiver configuration at a time. Simultaneous reception of FLARM and ADS-L is therefore generally not possible, or possible only to a limited extent.


Why are the two systems incompatible despite using largely identical radio technology?


Three differences in their transmission protocols are responsible.


1. Different rules for transmission timing and frequency selection

FLARM uses a time-coordinated frequency plan. Based on the time, devices know when to transmit or receive on each of the two frequencies.


ADS-L also uses both frequencies. For traffic and status messages, the current specification requires alternating between the two frequencies with each transmission. However, it does not define a time-based frequency plan or fixed transmission time slots for the M-band. Consequently, this frequency switching is not coordinated with the FLARM schedule.


The specification explains that alternating between frequencies is intended to facilitate reception by single-channel receivers: a receiver that remains on one frequency receives every second position message.


However, a FLARM receiver does not remain on one frequency. Instead, it switches frequencies according to the FLARM schedule. Whether it is listening on the correct frequency when the next ADS-L packet arrives is therefore not coordinated.


Without timing coordination, a single-channel receiver may miss approximately half of the ADS-L packets due to frequency selection alone, in a simplified model – even if the packets were otherwise compatible.


2. Different sync words

FLARM and ADS-L also use different so-called sync words.


A sync word works somewhat like a telephone number: the radio receiver responds only to signals carrying the correct identifier.


FLARM and ADS-L use different identifiers. As a result, ADS-L packets are rejected at the radio level by many existing FLARM receivers, even when they arrive on the correct frequency.


3. Different packet lengths and error checking

Another difference concerns the length of the transmitted data packets and their error-checking mechanisms.


Many energy-efficient radio transceivers are configured for a specific packet length and already check whether the received data is error-free within the radio chip itself.


FLARM and ADS-L use different packet formats and CRC methods. Existing receivers may therefore reject ADS-L packets even when the frequency and sync word match.


To make simultaneous reception as straightforward as possible, these parameters must also be coordinated.


Why were these differences introduced?

The three differences described above make it practically impossible for many existing FLARM receivers to receive FLARM and ADS-L simultaneously. The radio hardware can be configured for either FLARM or ADS-L, but not for both protocols at the same time.


However, it would be technically possible to coordinate the transmission protocols so that suitable existing FLARM radio hardware could receive both systems simultaneously with updated firmware.


If interoperability is explicitly one of the objectives of ADS-L, why were different transmission rules introduced that prevent precisely this interoperability?


What considerations led to these decisions? Which alternatives were evaluated? And what arguments speak against a common solution?


In our view, it is important to address these questions transparently during the further development of ADS-L. After all, this is a safety standard intended to benefit as many pilots as possible.


How could compatibility be improved?

In our view, four changes to ADS-L would be particularly important.


First, FLARM and ADS-L should use the same sync word in the M-band. This would allow suitable existing radio receivers to recognise packets from both systems, provided the other radio parameters are compatible.


Second, transmission time slots and frequency selection should be coordinated with FLARM. If a receiver knows at what time transmissions occur on which frequency, it can receive both protocols much more reliably.


Third, packet length and error checking should be compatible with existing FLARM radio hardware. Many energy-efficient radio transceivers expect a fixed packet length and perform error checking within the radio chip. If these parameters match, suitable existing receivers can pass both FLARM and ADS-L packets to their firmware, which can then distinguish between the two protocols.


Fourth, every ADS-L device should transmit regularly in the M-band, at least once every two seconds. The current specification does not require this. A device transmitting ADS-L exclusively in the O-band remains invisible to receivers monitoring only the M-band, even if all other transmission parameters are compatible.


The key advantage is that existing devices with suitable, firmware-updatable radio hardware would not require any new hardware. A firmware update would be sufficient – provided the respective manufacturer makes the update available.


This would allow existing, energy-efficient radio transceivers to continue being used. Neither additional receivers nor more complex radio hardware would be necessary for these devices.


Interestingly, the EASA ADS-L Issue 2 specification itself acknowledges this problem. It defines four M-band reception capability levels: none, occasional (above 5 percent), partial (above 40 percent), and full (above 80 percent). According to the specification, the "full" level can only be achieved by a receiver that monitors both frequencies simultaneously.

With a common, time-coordinated frequency plan, this limitation could be eliminated for suitable single-channel receivers.


Our proposal for ADS-L Issue 3 is therefore clear: A common sync word, a common time and frequency plan, compatible packet lengths and CRC methods, and regular M-band transmissions should enable existing FLARM radio hardware to reliably receive ADS-L with updated firmware.


This would improve interoperability without requiring suitable existing devices to be replaced with new hardware.


Why mutual detection is so important

The problem becomes particularly apparent when aircraft using different electronic systems encounter one another.


A paraglider equipped with ADS-L Out transmits its position, while a sailplane receives FLARM only.


Although the paraglider transmits an electronic signal, the existing FLARM device may be unable to receive it. The sailplane pilot consequently receives no corresponding collision warning.


Conversely, a paraglider pilot using an ADS-L Out-only transmitter cannot receive the sailplane's position either.


Both aircraft are equipped with electronic safety systems, yet neither can warn its pilot about the other.


The situation is different when both aircraft are appropriately equipped. FOCA recommends that sailplanes combine FLARM with ADS-L In/Out or ADS-B Out. If the sailplane transmits ADS-L, a paraglider equipped with ADS-L In can receive its position. If the paraglider also transmits FLARM, it can be detected by the sailplane's FLARM device.


FOCA is also planning ground infrastructure to relay traffic information. Such systems can improve traffic awareness. However, this information can only reach devices capable of receiving ADS-L. An ADS-L Out-only transmitter cannot benefit from it.


Reliable direct communication between aircraft remains particularly important in mountainous regions, where radio links to ground stations may be obstructed by terrain.


From electronic conspicuity to collision warning

A traffic display is not the same as a collision warning. Simply knowing another aircraft's position does not allow a device to reliably determine whether a dangerous encounter is imminent.


This requires predicting the future flight paths of the aircraft involved. A paraglider circling in a thermal behaves very differently from a fast-moving powered aircraft.


Turn rate is also important for accurate predictions. The current ADS-L position packet does not explicitly include this information; it must be estimated from successive position reports. Transmitting turn rate directly would enable faster and more reliable flight path predictions, particularly for circling aircraft.


A good collision warning algorithm must take such differences into account while avoiding unnecessary alerts. A system that frequently generates false alarms will quickly lose acceptance among pilots.


Without receiving traffic data, however, there is no basis for generating such warnings.

This is why we consider ADS-L In to be just as important a component of electronic conspicuity as ADS-L Out.


What does this mean for the next version of ADS-L?

EASA and the manufacturers involved are already working on the further development of ADS-L.

According to FLARM, ADS-L Issue 3 is expected to focus particularly on direct interoperability between aircraft and collision avoidance.

We explicitly welcome this objective. In our view, the following priorities should guide further development:


  1. Transmission and reception: Mutual traffic detection should become a fundamental objective.

  2. Interoperability: A common sync word, coordinated time and frequency plans, compatible packet lengths and CRC methods, and regular M-band transmissions should enable reception using existing hardware.

  3. Low power consumption: The technology must be suitable for small, battery-powered instruments.

  4. Open protocols: Manufacturers should be able to develop interoperable products.

  5. Reliable collision warnings: Position packets should include turn rate to help systems identify dangerous encounters and avoid unnecessary alerts.


A new standard does not necessarily have to replace all existing technologies. Often, it makes more sense to develop existing solutions further so that they can communicate with one another.


XC Tracer already supports transmission and reception

At XC Tracer, we have long maintained that electronic conspicuity should not be a one-way street.


Our current XC Tracer Maxx III and Mini V flight instruments therefore both transmit and receive ADS-L. The previous-generation Maxx II will receive the same functionality through a free firmware update.


Our devices also transmit FLARM, allowing them to be detected by FLARM equipment that cannot receive ADS-L. In addition, they exchange position data with other paragliding and hang-gliding instruments via FANET.


Our goal is to detect as many relevant aircraft as possible while remaining electronically visible to others.


We place particular emphasis on low power consumption, reliable hardware, and ease of use.


We support the introduction of ADS-L while advocating for its continued development and improvement.


Our recommendation: Buy devices with both ADS-L In and Out

With the planned ADS-L mandate, many pilots in Switzerland will need to purchase new equipment in the coming years.


We therefore strongly recommend buying only devices that can both transmit and receive ADS-L.


An ADS-L Out-only transmitter may satisfy the proposed minimum legal requirements. However, it provides its pilot with no means of receiving ADS-L signals from other aircraft.

Ideally, a device should also transmit FLARM so that it can be detected by FLARM devices without ADS-L reception capability, and should support FANET. What matters is that received traffic information can actually be displayed or used to generate warnings.


Pilots purchasing a new flight instrument today should not merely aim to comply with the upcoming equipment mandate. They should also invest in their own safety.


Our conclusion: Not just being visible, but being able to see others.

ADS-L offers a major opportunity to improve safety in European airspace. Its planned introduction in Switzerland could help make significantly more aircraft electronically visible in the future.


But electronic conspicuity alone does not provide collision warnings.

A transmitter alone does not protect its pilot from overlooking another aircraft. And a transmitted signal only provides a tangible benefit if another system can receive and meaningfully process it.


The long-term objective should therefore be clear:


All aircraft should be able to transmit their positions and receive the positions of other aircraft – regardless of who manufactured their equipment.


Open standards, compatibility with existing devices, and intelligent collision warning algorithms are essential to achieving this goal.


Ultimately, the objective is not simply to put as many ADS-L transmitters into the air as possible.


The objective is to prevent collisions.


Sources and further reading

 
 
 

Comments


 XC Tracer GmbH / Junkerngasse 53 / 3011 Bern / Switzerland          +41 (0)79 478 64 14          info@xctracer.com  

 XC Tracer GmbH / Junkerngasse 53 / 3011 Bern / Switzerland          +41 (0)79 478 64 14          info@xctracer.com  

bottom of page